Confusing and Contradictory


Last time, I told you that I had done a lot of reading and researching in my blogging absence.  I also mentioned that a lot of what I was reading conflicted with the knowledge I had previously accumulated.  Let me expound on this…

Shortly after we went on GAPS, I began to see a lot of articles in the blogosphere about the Paleo diet.  This was awesome, because GAPS and Paleo are very similar.  The Paleo diet suggests no grains, dairy, legumes, or refined sugars.  GAPS allows certain legumes and some dairy, but is more strict about sweeteners.  Still, most recipes coming across the Paleo blogs were GAPS legal.  As the Paleo movement has continued to grow, more and more science has come in to back it up.  More and more people have success with it.  And more and more, it aligns with GAPS, especially something called Autoimmune Paleo, which is another healing diet specifically for people with autoimmune disorders.

I also began to read more blogs promoting “Traditional” diets such as are described in the book Nourishing Traditions: The Cookbook that Challenges Politically Correct Nutrition and the Diet Dictocrats
and promoted by the Weston A. Price Foundation (WAPF).  These often crossed circles with Paleo and GAPS, because all of them endorse REAL food.  The major difference is that most WAPF’ers eat grains, especially if they are soaked or fermented (think sourdough).  Still, a lot of helpful information.  I knew GAPS was a temporary diet, so learning about proper preparation of grains is something I wanted to do.

So far, so good, right?  And then came Matt Stone.  And you’re thinking, who is he and why do we care?  I thought the same thing at first.  But he kept showing up.  Seemingly everywhere I turned, there was someone talking about Matt Stone and his wonderful ideas.  So I followed the rabbit trail…

Matt Stone has a blog called 180 Degree Health, which I am not linking because I find his writing to be brash, rude, and sometimes foul-mouthed.  I don’t care how good your ideas are, there’s no need for that.  Google at your own risk.  However, there are a whole lot of other ways to find out what he is all about.  One of the WAPF blogs I follow, Cheeseslave, embraced his teachings early on and has since been very vocal about his ideaology.  Here it is in a nutshell: Health is all about metabolism, at the cellular level.  The best way to track metabolic health is to track your body temperature.  If it averages less than 98.6, you are not in good metabolic health.  To raise your body temperature, you need more carbs, more calories, more salt, more sleep, less water, and less strenuous exercise (cardio).  The advice being thrown around the blogosphere is this: JUST EAT THE FOOD.  Whatever it is, whatever you want, just eat it.  No restrictions.  No special diets.  No calorie counting.  Just eat whatever you want to get that body temperature up.  Bloggers started latching on to this, shouting it from the rooftops.  Gladly proclaiming that they have gained 10, 20, 50 pounds but it didn’t matter because they had raised their body temperature and felt really great!  Those same bloggers saying that Paleo is terrible and GAPS should be dumped.

Now, I’m not saying that he’s completely wrong.  Most of what he says makes a lot of sense.  I get what he is saying about metabolic health, at the cellular level.  I understand the science.  We do need carbs, salt, sleep.  We probably don’t need as much water as society tells us we need.  Maybe there are other ways to exercise that are easier on our body.  But I really take issue with “eat whatever you want”.  It’s not that simple.

Then I started second guessing myself.  What if it is that simple??  As I began to get tired of cooking, tired of restricting food, I thought maybe we would test his little theory.  We brought back grains, potatoes.  We eat cake and ice cream at parties (and sometimes in between).  We ate whatever we wanted on vacation.  We get frozen pizzas.  Very non-GAPS!

The result of all this “just eating the food”?  My body temperature has not gone up.  Not one iota.  My joints hurt.  I’ve gained over 10 pounds.  I’m tired.  I think it’s not that simple.

So here we are, in a no man’s land of sorts, trying to sift through a whole lot of conflicting information.  Almost all of it makes perfect sense in theory.  But in practice, for me, it doesn’t seem to work.  My body does not approve.  Even though I have many of the symptoms of an out of whack metabolism, “just eating the food” isn’t helping.  I’m obviously missing something here.  I’m going to keep digging, try to find out what my body needs (or doesn’t need) to be happy again.


**This post contains affiliate links.


3 thoughts on “Confusing and Contradictory

  1. I think your last sentence is the most important: find what works for YOUR body. There are lots of theories and you can read all about them, but the one that works is the one that you feel good on. Keep it up and you will figure it out. I love that you are seeking for answers. They are out there; you will find them. Good job!

  2. I agree, check out the metabolic diet, it will answer a LOT of questions and also check out RBTI on Matt Stones website. Also check out the Pfeiffer institute which deals with metabolic ‘quirks’, don’t over think, experiment once you have the info and see what works for you, use common sense and eat the foods that are real and give you the most energy.

  3. I have been going along the same path. I found WAPF about 5 years ago, and then gaps. We slowly worked out way towards gaps, definitely doing lots of healing along the way. And then when I was hoping to start intro gaps with us and take a few months to really heal, Matt Stone was doing his own writing on the idea of metabolism and listening to our bodies, etc. I was really torn between both realities. I still see both sides and don’t have ‘answers’, but I’ve come to think that that is how life really is. We want definite answers to life’s problems, but in reality, it’s more of a dance we dance with them. It takes constant vigilance, prayer and thinking, to be constantly moving forward. In some ways, it’s freeing not having to be so strict, but also, I’ve found there was a different freedom in not having to ‘think’ so much and just assume you are moving forward. We try and dance that dance daily, some days we do better then others. But I really don’t want ‘junk’ food, and neither does my family for the most part. We eats lots of really good foods every day. I do spend a lot of time in the kitchen, but it’s bearable and mostly good and fun. we all have better moods, not as intense of allergy issues and more energy. We still have issues we need work on. or rather, that our body needs to work on. But I think/hope that we are moving in the right direction finally, and it’s just a constant watching and reading and learning and thinking and praying.
    Don’t give up! It’s so encouraging to read someone else has had the same issues I’ve had.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s